1. Introduction: The “Reselling is Dead” Myth
Walk into any digital community for entrepreneurs, and you’ll hear the same cynical refrain: online reselling is too saturated, the margins are gone, and the “golden age” is over. However, the 2025 performance data from one independent business proves that the model isn’t just alive—it’s thriving for those who treat it like a professional operation.
This past year, creators Carrie and Kyle managed a high-volume business while navigating the ultimate “human” disruption: the birth of a new baby and the demands of homeschooling. By treating their operation as a structured Monday-through-Friday, 9-to-5 job, they hit a six-figure net profit without the “hustle culture” requirement of working crazy hours.
2. Takeaway 1: The Reality Gap Between Gross Sales and Net Profit
In reselling, “gross revenue” is a vanity metric; “net profit” is your sanity metric. While this business generated a staggering 281,248.37 in gross sales**, the actual amount that hit their personal bank account was **98,920.46. As an analyst, I view this ~35% net profit margin as a massive win for a home-based, two-person team.
To understand the “surprising math,” we have to look at the friction required to scale. The $182,327.91 “gap” consists of the following essential costs of doing business:
- Platform & Ad Fees: $50,454.72 (including $14,000 in extra eBay promotions to drive volume).
- Shipping Labels: $53,999.83.
- Sales Tax: $14,195.67.
- Inventory Cost of Goods: $46,823.59.
- Operating Expenses (OpEx): $1,876.83 in supplies (poly mailers/bags), $739.92 in subscriptions, and a $240 PO Box.
3. Takeaway 2: AI is No Longer a Luxury—It’s a Time-Saver
For a small team, technology is the only way to increase volume without increasing hours. Carrie’s approach to AI is a masterclass in intentionality: she famously stated, “I won’t use AI listing tools until they become faster than me.”
In 2025, that threshold was finally met. By integrating AI listing tools, Carrie reduced her daily workload for 45 listings from 1.5–2 hours down to just 1–1.5 hours. For an independent creator, saving 30 minutes a day isn’t just a convenience; it is the strategic breathing room needed to manage a household while maintaining a consistent listing cadence.
4. Takeaway 3: The “Pay Raise” of Cross-Listing
Platform loyalty can be a silent profit killer. By utilizing the Nifty subscription to cross-list inventory from eBay to Poshmark, the business tapped into a buyer demographic that rarely crosses over. Carrie views this move not as “more work,” but as a literal pay raise through increased inventory velocity.
“I just view it as that stuff will eventually sell on eBay, but because we’re putting it in front of more eyeballs and people who may never even shop on eBay ever in their life… we’re just getting those sales faster.”
Reaching new “eyeballs” ensures that capital isn’t tied up in stale inventory, allowing for a faster reinvestment cycle.
5. Takeaway 4: Financial Intentionality and the “Multiple Account” Method
To prevent the emotional burnout of “Where did the money go?” this business utilizes a Profit First financial structure through the Relay banking platform. Instead of one large pool of cash, they separate funds into multiple accounts for taxes, inventory, and owner’s pay.
This level of financial rigor is a game-changer. By integrating Relay with tools like QuickBooks or Xero, they simplified their tax season and ensured that the $98k net profit was a protected number, not a guess. Separating money with intention provides the “emotional clarity” needed to make big-picture scaling decisions.
6. Takeaway 5: Returns are a Metric, Not a Personal Failure
The business issued $14,897 in refunds over the year. While that number is jarring, the analyst’s perspective reveals a healthy 4% return rate. Most of these returns were tied to the “fit” challenges of the pants and jeans market.
Rather than taking returns personally, the team used this data to pivot. They began shifting their inventory mix toward shirts and jackets to mitigate fit issues and lower the return rate further. This is the difference between an amateur and a pro: a pro uses return data to refine their sourcing strategy rather than complaining about “difficult buyers.”
7. Takeaway 6: Reclaiming the 40-Hour Work Week
The most impressive metric of 2025 wasn’t the money—it was the time. Because Carrie was recovering from childbirth and managing a newborn, the couple redesigned their workflow to fit a 40–45 hour combined work week.
Kyle handled the physical labor: 5 hours of sourcing, 1.5 hours of photography, and 30 minutes of packaging daily. Carrie handled the digital side, focusing on AI-assisted listings. They even “banked” work ahead of time to allow for paid vacations, proving that you don’t have to be a slave to the “refresh” button to earn a six-figure income.
8. Conclusion: Your Business, Your Rules
The 2025 review of this business serves as a powerful reminder: reselling is a customizable vehicle. Whether you are recovering from a major life event or homeschooling your children, you can build a system that serves your family rather than one that consumes it.
Success in this space requires you to block out the cynicism, keep your head down, and stay focused on the “math” of your own progress. As the market evolves, be the “shining light” that looks for opportunities where others see obstacles.
If you could automate just one hour of your daily grind, what part of your life would you take back first?
Leave a comment